Category Archives: professional judgment

Marking Essays Causes Mental Depletion

We always knew it, didn’t we? At the start of a session we’re more meticulous about our marking than we are later in the process when we are far more likely to make a ‘gut’ decision or a ‘near enough is good … Continue reading

Posted in professional judgment, reliability, standards, writing assessment issues | Leave a comment

Off with the head – China had the answer to plagiarism hundreds of years ago.

Plagiarism arises again and again as an issue in assessment. Suggestions are made that students need to be educated to avoid it, assessment tasks are devised to minimize it and assessors are vigilant to detect it (using electronic means). It … Continue reading

Posted in plagiarism, professional judgment, reliability, validity | Leave a comment

What is Professional Judgement?

In his article on professional judgement and disposition Dottin quotes two earlier authors. Both quotes offer shallow, out of context ideas about professional judgement (PJ) and do nothing to get to the nub of what it is.  After reading Dottin’s … Continue reading

Posted in professional judgment | Leave a comment

Maintaining standards in assessment

AUTC is the Australia Universities Teaching Committee. In 2002 they issued several papers aimed at assisting universities to maintain standards in assessment and to respond to new issues. Paper One – A new era in assessing student learning Two new … Continue reading

Posted in plagiarism, professional judgment, standards, technology | Leave a comment

Fundamental Assessment Principles …

As his title suggests McMillan sets out to elucidate the basic principles of assessment. He highlights the role of professional judgment ‘whether the judgment occurs in constructing test questions, scoring essays, creating rubrics, grading participation, combining scores, or interpreting standardized … Continue reading

Posted in professional judgment, reliability, validity, writing assessment issues | Leave a comment